Menu
Search
Menu
Close
By Cook's Illustrated Published January 2017

Bundt Pans

Published January 2017 Behind the Testing

How we tested

A Bundt pan is a special tube pan with decorative ridges or fluting. It was introduced in 1950 by Nordic Ware at the request of a Minneapolis-area Jewish women’s group whose members wanted a lighter, easier-to-use version of the ring-shaped cast-iron pans used to make kugelhopf, a Central European yeast cake. But the pan didn’t truly start to become popular until 1966, when a chocolate Bundt cake called the Tunnel of Fudge took second place in the Pillsbury Bake-Off. Sales boomed as home bakers across the country sought to make this cake for themselves. Today, Bundt pans are a common sight in kitchens everywhere.

We wanted to find the best Bundt pan—one that would be easy to use and would effortlessly release attractive, evenly browned cakes. So we bought seven 11- to 15-cup nonstick pans priced from $8.79 to $30.99 and used them to make our Classic Yellow Bundt Cake.

We were pleased to learn that all the Bundt pans made excellent, consistently browned cakes. Pans with dark interiors produced cakes that were a slightly deeper brown but were still entirely acceptable. Better still, all the pans released the cakes equally well, with no sticking. Capacity wasn’t an issue—because the pans differed primarily in height but not in diameter, 11.25-cup and 12-cup models produced cakes that had about the same dimensions as the one made in the 15-cup pan. And although we were concerned that some of the smaller pans might not be big enough to hold larger doughs—like our yeast-raised Monkey Bread—as they proofed and baked, even the 11.25-cup models did a fine job of containing the risen dough.

In the end, it was the design of each pan that mattered most—and specifically how that design affected ease of use and cake appearance. We preferred pans with handles, which made them easier to maneuver while greasing them, removing them from the oven, and turning out cakes. And we liked pans that had sharp, well-defined ridges because they produced more attractive, impressive-looking cakes than pans with gentle waves or fluting. As in our last testing, the Nordic Ware Anniversary Bundt Pan, $30.99, reigned supreme. It had thick, easy-to-grip handles, and it turned out perfectly browned cakes with dramatic peaks and valleys.

Methodology

We tested seven nonstick Bundt pans with capacities of 11 to 15 cups, priced from $8.79 to $30.99. We measured their capacities and then used them to make our Classic Yellow Bundt Cake, evaluating the pans for ease of use, release, and cake appearance. To double-check that pan capacity was not a significant factor, we used the smallest, darkest pan (the Norpro Nonstick Fluted Tube Pan) to proof and bake yeast-raised Monkey Bread. All pans were washed by hand 10 times and examined afterward for signs of damage.

Ease of Use: Pans that had handles were easier to grip and flip; they received more points.

Cake Appearance: We gave more points to pans that had deep, well-defined ridges or fluting.

Release: Pans that released the cakes easily received full points.

Get the story

The Results

Winner
Highly Recommended

Nordic Ware Anniversary Bundt Pan

The biggest model in our testing, our winner also had large handles, making it easy to grip, maneuver, and flip. And it had the deepest, most well-defined ridges, producing the most eye-catching cakes in our tests.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$30.99*
Recommended

Nordic Ware Anniversary 12 Cup Formed Bundt Pan

This pan had handles that were just a touch smaller than our winner’s, and while it made attractive cakes, their decorative crests and troughs were a little less well-defined.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$17.99*

Wilton Perfect Results Fluted Tube Pan

We liked this smaller pan for its handles, which were engraved with grip-enhancing ridges. The fluting of the cakes, however, was a bit too shallow, producing a somewhat less memorable-looking cake.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$16.11*

Norpro Nonstick Fluted Tube Pan

Without handles, this smaller pan was a little harder to maneuver, and its dark interior meant that cakes browned a tiny bit more deeply. It produced cakes with gentle curves, not sharply etched peaks.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$15.36*

Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware 10-in Bundt Pan

This pan lacked handles, so it was harder to grip and flip. The ridges on its cakes were a bit wimpy.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$21.99*

Baker’s Secret Essentials Fluted Bundt Tube Pan

Because it lacked handles, this pan was harder to grease and maneuver. And its very gentle fluting made for a fairly undistinguished-looking cake.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$8.79*
Recommended with Reservations

Cuisinart 9.5" Fluted Cake Pan

Without handles, this pan was difficult to maneuver. Its fluting was fairly nondescript, and unfortunately, seams encircling the inner tube produced an unsightly crease around the center of the cake.

More Details
Release
Ease of Use
Cake Appearance
$19.90*