Menu
Search
Menu
Close

We make mistakes so you don’t have to.

Get unlimited access to ALL our foolproof recipes, unbiased equipment reviews and ingredient ratings. Guaranteed to work for you.

Try CooksIllustrated.com Free for 14 Days

Email is required
How we use your email address

Choosing Seafood for Bouillabaisse

By Cook's Illustrated Published September 2001

We've found that the best bouillabaisse is made from a combination of three groups of seafood.

We've found that the best bouillabaisse is made from a combination of three groups of seafood.

The fun of bouillabaise is that one mouthful can contain buttery flakes of ocean perch, the bite of monkfish, the chew of a little mollusk, and the slippery firmness of shrimp. A tasting determined that a combination of three groups of seafood was best: firm-fleshed fish, flaky fish, and shellfish. Three fish and three shellfish make a great combination--or go with four fish and two shellfish if you prefer. Doubtless many freshwater fish would work well in a bouillabaisse recipe, but we limited our testing to saltwater fish in the interest of time.

RECOMMENDED

For best results choose at least one fish from each category:

Firm

Chilean Sea Bass

grouper

haddock

halibut

John Dory

monkfish

striped bass

tilapia

Flaky

hake

ocean perch

red snapper

Thai snapper

Shellfish

mussels

sea scallops

shrimp

NOT RECOMMENDED

Too Oily:

bluefish

mackerel

salmon

Incompatible Cooking Rates

clams

cod

sole

Too Meaty

mahi-mahi

swordfish

tuna