Plush, Meaty Pastelón

More elaborate preparations featuring plantains layered with meat and other fillings exist across Latin America, but I can’t imagine any that would make me feel happier or more replete than pastelón. Every Puerto Rican family has their own version of the dish, whose name translates as “big pie.” Here is mine, based largely on my grandmother’s, but with tweaks to ensure that its savory-sweet flavors pop.

There is only one thing essential to pastelón: The fruit must be very ripe so that it has the requisite softness and sweetness to provide a counterpoint to the picadillo. Typically, the peeled plantains are each sliced along their length into planks, but I found it challenging to make even slices with such long cuts. Instead, I first halved the plantains crosswise and then sliced each half lengthwise into three thin slabs. When I slipped these stubbier pieces into a skillet with hot oil (3/4 cup did the trick—just enough to allow them to move freely), they were also easier to flip during cooking. Once the plantains darkened to a deep golden brown and crisped at the edges, I drained them on paper towels. A little salt and they were good to go.

On to the picadillo: I wanted a casserole that didn’t taste overly rich, so I opted for 90 percent lean ground beef. For the sofrito, I pulsed onion and garlic in a food processor with plenty of cilantro, its grassy-citrusy cousin culantro, and a musky Cubanelle pepper. But instead of sautéing this flavor base and then cooking the raw meat in it with tomato sauce, I browned the beef in the skillet first to amplify its meatiness and then further boosted its savory flavor by sprinkling it with a healthy dose of sazón, a heady Puerto Rican mix of salt, dried garlic, onion, black pepper, oregano, cumin, and achiote. I removed the browned beef from the pan, added my sofrito, and sautéed it for several minutes before stirring in tomato sauce (the canned kind is perfect) and simmering the mixture long enough for a flavorful fond to begin forming on the bottom and edges of the pan. I added the beef back to the skillet with a couple tablespoons of alcaparrado, a jarred combination of green olives, capers, and pimentos that gives the island’s version of picadillo its characteristic punch. Some cooks chop the mixture, but I love the tangy burst of biting into a meaty olive, so I left it whole. I cooked the picadillo until the sauce tightened and clung to the meat. A pour of white vinegar brought all the sweet, savory, and vibrant flavors into focus.

I fanned half the fried plantains across a baking dish and, after some experimentation, poured beaten eggs over just this bottom layer instead of the whole assembly, which gave the casserole a sturdier structure for lifting slices out of the pan. I smoothed on the picadillo, shingled the remaining plantains over the top, and debated the final question: cheese or no cheese? The most traditional versions, including my grandmother’s, eschew it, but I decided on a smattering of shredded Monterey Jack. After 20 minutes in the oven, it melted oozily over the velvety-soft plantains and tender bits of beef, making this already ridiculously good dish even more comforting and appealing.