Testing Six-Cup Muffin Tins

To find the best six-cup muffin tin, we gathered six models, priced from about $11 to about $26. The pans in our lineup were made from either metal or porcelain and ranged in color from white to gold to silver. All but two had nonstick coatings. We used each tin to bake Basic Muffins, Easy Birthday Cupcakes, and Muffin Tin Frittatas. We examined how easily food released, as well as the food’s overall shape and how evenly it browned. We also evaluated how comfortable the tins were to hold while moving them into and out of the oven and how easy they were to clean.

While we were happy with the foods produced in most of the tins, our results varied. The cups were shaped differently from pan to pan. Some were taller and narrower, while others were shorter and wider. Those differences affected the shapes of the baked goods they produced. Only one pan was a real problem, turning out unacceptably squat baked goods. Because the cups were shaped differently, capacites varied slightly from pan to pan, ranging from about 5 tablespoons to about 6½ tablespoons per cup. (For comparison, the cups of our favorite 12-cup muffin tin each hold roughly 7 tablespoons.)

The two models that had the smallest cup capacities offered less than ½ inch of space between the cups. As batter rose in each cup, the expanding tops of the cupcakes ran into each other. When we pulled one of these tins from the oven, we had what looked like one giant cupcake instead of six. Our favorite tins had larger cups as well as about 1 inch of space between the cups, giving us baked goods that were separated and distinct.

The dimensions of the pans also affected how easy they were to handle. Some of these pans had very little space around their rims. The rims on the smallest tins were just ½ inch wide, so we didn’t have a convenient place to put our hands. With these tins, we had to pay special attention to avoid accidentally dropping them or poking the baked goods with our oven mitt. Pans with rims that were at least 1 inch wide were easier to handle. We liked that we could securely grab them without inadvertently leaving a fingerprint in our food or batter on our mitts, a feature we liked in our favorite 12-cup tin, too.

We also considered the browning on the baked goods. The tops of the foods baked in all the tins looked evenly browned, and the foods were done within the time ranges cited in each recipe. It wasn’t until we removed the foods from their tins that we noticed differences. The materials and colors of the pans determined how darkly (or not) the sides and the bottoms of food browned. The white porcelain and gold-colored metal tins produced golden-brown food, while the darker metal pans produced food with darker browning. One pan didn't brown food well. It was made from shiny stainless steel, which reflects heat from the oven more than it absorbs it, so its baked goods turned out pale and flabby. We preferred the tins that gave us evenly browned baked goods.

Four of the muffin tins had nonstick coatings, so they each released foods easily. These nonstick models were also easy to wash. One stainless-steel tin without a nonstick coating released food cleanly, though not as easily as those with nonstick coatings. The other tin without a nonstick coating, the porcelain model, didn't fare well. Small pieces of the muffins were left behind, stuck to the cups’ walls. The porcelain pan was especially difficult to clean because it was quite heavy—more than 3 pounds—and it became slippery in the sink.

Our favorite six-cup muffin tin is the Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Muffin Pan, 6-Well. The cups have large capacities, about 6½ tablespoons, and there’s enough space in between each cup to ensure that the contents don’t run into each other as they bake. The extended rim around the exterior of the tin makes it easy to securely move the tin into and out of the oven. Gold-colored, this tin produced beautiful golden-brown muffins and cupcakes with evenly browned sides and bottoms. Food also released without extra effort and left nothing behind. As a result, we were able to clean this tin quickly and easily. At roughly half the price, the Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick/MD 6 Cup Muffin Pan is also a great choice. Because the rim is less spacious than our winner’s, it was harder to find a secure place to hold the hot tin while wearing oven mitts. However, food released easily, and it produced evenly browned baked goods that didn’t run together. If you have a toaster oven and/or limited storage space, or if you regularly make half batches of muffins or cupcakes, either of these pans will make an excellent addition to your bakeware collection.