Menu
Search
Menu
Close

We make mistakes so you don’t have to.

Try CooksIllustrated.com Free for 14 Days

Email is required
How we use your email address

Is It Better to Brine Meat Longer?

By Lan Lam Published

Brining longer doesn’t necessarily mean juicier meat.

Brining meat helps it cook up juicy and well seasoned. When brining larger cuts that require a long soak, such as roasts and whole poultry, we typically suggest a time range. But while it’s important to brine the meat for at least the minimum amount of time, don’t brine longer than the suggested range. The far end of the range is built in for the cook’s convenience, not because the meat will be significantly juicier or taste more seasoned. To prove it, we tracked how fast salt moves into a roast over time.

Experiment

We made three batches of our standard brine and soaked pork loin roasts for 2, 4, and 24 hours. Then we cut each roast into 1-inch-thick slices and tested the slices for salt penetration by applying first potassium chromate and then silver nitrate, which turned orange at first and then clear again where the salt penetrated; we then measured the width of the rings of unstained meat.

We painted chemicals onto brined pork to determine salt penetration after 2, 4, and 24 hours.

Results

The rate at which salt moved into the meat slowed significantly after 2 hours. After 2 hours, salt had penetrated ⅓ inch; after 4 hours, it had penetrated ½ inch; and after 24 hours, ¾ inch.

Explanation

Salt naturally moves from areas of high concentration to those of low concentration. And the larger the difference in concentration, the more quickly the sodium ions travel into the meat. At the beginning of the brining time, there’s a huge difference in concentration: The interior of the meat has none of the salt, and the surface of the meat has a lot. As the salt travels through the meat, the difference becomes smaller: The concentration on the outside is lowered, and almost all areas inside the meat have at least some sodium ions, so the rate of diffusion drops. Furthermore, while sodium ions in the brine continue to penetrate the exterior of the pork, that reaction slows as well because the outer layer of pork already contains some sodium.

(The upshot: In the first 4 hours, salt traveled farther than it did in the next 20 hours.)

Takeaway

Because the returns for brining diminish over time, the first few hours of brining a large roast (or the first 30 minutes or so for smaller cuts) are critical, but soaking the meat until the end of a recommended time range—or even a few hours longer—won’t produce an appreciable difference in salt penetration.

Recipes That Brine Meat for Juicy, Tender Results

Recipe Perfect Poached Chicken Breasts

Hardly anyone poaches chicken anymore—and with good reason: The classic technique is fussy and leads to bland meat. We set out to change that.

Recipe Grilled Chicken Souvlaki

Bright lemon flavor and charred-yet-moist, evenly cooked meat are the hallmarks of good souvlaki. They’re also the hardest traits to get right.

Recipe Best Roast Chicken with Root Vegetables

The secret to a perfect marriage of roast chicken and root vegetables is to keep them apart until the wedding day.

Recipe Cuban-Style Oven-Roasted Pork

Garlicky, citrus-infused pork is a natural for the backyard grill. Unfortunately, so are dry meat, burnt skin, and faint flavors. We grill-roasted 200 pounds of pork to get it right.

Comments