Artisanal Cream Cheese

From Cook's Illustrated | July/August 2014

We mail-ordered three artisanal cream cheeses to see if they could beat our supermarket favorite.

Overview:

While artisanal cream cheese won’t be putting big national brands out of business anytime soon, we wondered if a small-batch, handmade approach to this everyday supermarket staple could take it to the next level. To find out, we mail-ordered three cheeses, from Vermont, Michigan, and Virginia.

To focus on flavor, we sampled the cheeses plain. Tasters gave top marks to the most complex-tasting cheeses, which had strong notes of herbs and radishes. We continued our evaluation with the classic application: the bagel test. If our tasters were expecting a schmear of Philadelphia Brand, they quickly realized that this was a different thing altogether. Instead of the familiar tacky, dense consistency of a foil-wrapped block, tasters noted that these small-batch samples were looser and lighter. Two of the three spread easily over bagels and were both so fluffy that they brought to mind lightly whipped cream. Tasters liked the third sample, too, but it lost points for its drier, almost crumbly consistency, which made it harder to spread.… read more

While artisanal cream cheese won’t be putting big national brands out of business anytime soon, we wondered if a small-batch, handmade approach to this everyday supermarket staple could take it to the next level. To find out, we mail-ordered three cheeses, from Vermont, Michigan, and Virginia.

To focus on flavor, we sampled the cheeses plain. Tasters gave top marks to the most complex-tasting cheeses, which had strong notes of herbs and radishes. We continued our evaluation with the classic application: the bagel test. If our tasters were expecting a schmear of Philadelphia Brand, they quickly realized that this was a different thing altogether. Instead of the familiar tacky, dense consistency of a foil-wrapped block, tasters noted that these small-batch samples were looser and lighter. Two of the three spread easily over bagels and were both so fluffy that they brought to mind lightly whipped cream. Tasters liked the third sample, too, but it lost points for its drier, almost crumbly consistency, which made it harder to spread.

But how would these artisanal products fare in baked applications? Our dessert recipes, like most published recipes, were developed using national supermarket brands that contain stabilizers. No surprise, then, that stabilizer-free artisanal cheeses led to textural problems in recipes for cheesecake and cream cheese frosting, in which the cream cheese was the primary ingredient. In the cheesecake, excess moisture sank to the bottom, while frostings made with each of the three cheeses looked curdled. But as a secondary ingredient in cream cheese brownies, the artisanal cream cheeses excelled, providing a pleasant, tangy contrast to the rich chocolate. In fact, all three brands in our tasting beat out brownies made with our supermarket favorite.

THE BOTTOM LINE: For baking recipes in which cream cheese is the primary ingredient, we recommend sticking with supermarket brands. However, if you are making our Cook's Illustrated Cream Cheese Brownies, or if you want a superior spread for your bagels, artisanal cream cheese will deliver a more complex flavor and lighter texture that is well worth the money. (If you want to use it as a secondary ingredient in another baking recipe, proper results may require some testing and adjustment.) Our favorite won the top spot for its full flavor and well-rounded balance between saltiness, tanginess, and creaminess.

less
  • Product Tested

    Price*

  • Prices are subject to change.
  • Highly Recommended - Winner

    Zingerman’s Creamery Fresh Cream Cheese

    Made at a creamery founded by the Ann Arbor delicatessen of the same name, this cheese won top marks for being supercreamy and smooth, with “impressive depth of flavor.” The saltiest cheese in the lineup, it also boasted “floral” and “herbal” notes, with hints of “lavender” and “radish.”

    $15 for 1-lb tub ($0.94 per oz), plus shipping

  • Recommended

    Night Sky Farm Fresh Cream Cheese

    We found this cream cheese from a Virginia farm to be “moist” and “light,” with a “very smooth, pleasant texture.” Its tangy, “lemony” brightness reminded tasters of sour cream and crème fraîche. They also noted appealing “earthy undertones” when the cream cheese was sampled on its own. These flavors were harder to detect when the cream cheese was spread on a bagel.

    $13.50 for two 8-oz packages ($0.84 per oz), plus shipping

  • Recommended

    Champlain Valley Creamery Old Fashion Organic Cream Cheese

    The least like supermarket cream cheese, this Vermont offering had a drier, more crumbly texture that tasters likened to fresh goat cheese. While some tasters found this “off-putting,” others described it as “enjoyable.” This cream cheese’s flavor was the most “subtle” of the lineup. Though still “tangy” and “tart,” it was the “buttery” and “milky” notes of dairy and “fresh cream” that stood out most to tasters.

    $4.50 for 8-oz tub ($0.56 per oz), plus shipping

*PRICES SUBJECT TO CHANGE
In My Favorites
Please Wait…
Remove Favorite
Add to custom collection