Cook's Illustrated

Pasta and Ground Lamb Casserole (Pastitsio)

Editors’ Choice Cookbook Collection.  From The Best International Recipe.

Why this recipe works:

When developing our pastitsio recipe, we began with the lamb and tomato sauce, browning the lamb and then draining the rendered fat to keep the casserole from becoming too greasy. A combination of crushed tomatoes and tomato paste yielded the tomato intensity and saucy texture that we were after for our pastitsio recipe. We liked elbow macaroni best, and we cooked it very shy of al dente so that the pasta wouldn’t bake up soft and soggy in the casserole. We tested the béchamel next, and found that the casserole required a surprising amount to keep it moist. Because the quantity was so large, the béchamel had to have good flavor—we enhanced it with onion, garlic, Pecorino cheese, and nutmeg.

Serves 6 to 8

The baking dish is very full when it goes into the oven. Just in case it overflows, bake it on a foil-lined baking sheet. Do not substitute low-fat or nonfat milk in the sauce.


Ingredients

This page is for
Editors’ Choice Cookbook Collection members only

What is the Editors’ Choice Cookbook Collection?

Start a 14-day Free Trial Today

Start a 14-Day FREE TRIAL to BOTH CooksIllustrated.com and our Editors’ Choice Cookbook Collection today for full access to 20 years of Cook’s Illustrated magazine's recipes, equipment testings, and ingredient ratings, plus the Editors’ Choice Cookbook Collection of foolproof recipes hand-picked from our 18 Cook’s Illustrated cookbooks.

How we use your e-mail address
Start a FREE TRIAL online membership
 
America's Test Kitchen