Cook's Illustrated

How to Grill Onions

Published July 1, 2006.

Grilled onions usually cook up blackened outside and raw inside. Is there a better way?

The Problem

Onions are hard to manage on the grill. They slip through the grate, burn, or cook to a leathery texture on the outside while remaining raw on the inside.

The Goal

We wanted a simple cooking method that would produce an ideal caramelized exterior but that still cooked the onion through to the centermost slice.

The Solution

Because sliced onion rounds exposed the greatest surface area, they were the logical cut for grilling, and slices cut 1/2 half inch thick were best. We found the onions too susceptible to burning over high heat; moderate heat, with the onions covered with a foil pan, was just right. We stopped the rings from plunging through the grate by skewering them. After developing our grilling technique, we conducted a taste test to choose the best variety. Spanish onions won; tasters loved their meaty texture and "complex" flavor profile.

list of recipes

EMAIL THIS TO A FRIEND

Add from my address book Cancel
Start a FREE TRIAL online membership
 
America's Test Kitchen