Baking Stones

Note: Cook's Illustrated continuously updates our equipment reviews and taste tests. The written content below is the most up-to-date information available and may not match what appears in the video segment.

Published September 1, 2010. From Cook's Illustrated.

We fired up our oven and baked pizzas and calzones on five stones ($24-$90), evaluating their performance and design.

Overview:

Baking stones simulate a brick oven in your home oven, absorbing and radiating intense, consistent heat to produce crisp, golden-brown pizza, calzones, and bread. We fired up our oven and baked pizzas and calzones on five stones ($24-$90), evaluating their performance and design. Overly hefty slabs—one heavyweight approached 20 pounds—lost points, as did inefficiently sized models. One stone spanned wider than most home ovens, while others barely had enough girth to accommodate a large pizza. For more square footage, we preferred rectangles to rounds, and deeper-browning clay and stone models to cement. The latter material not only produced spotty, pale crusts but emitted noxious fumes. Our previous favorite from Old Stone Oven couldn’t be beat, crisping crusts on a roomy, foot-elevated surface that eased lifting.

Baking stones simulate a brick oven in your home oven, absorbing and radiating intense, consistent heat to produce crisp, golden-brown pizza, calzones, and bread. We fired up our oven and baked pizzas and calzones on five stones ($24-$90), evaluating their performance and design. Overly hefty slabs—one heavyweight approached 20 pounds—lost points, as did inefficiently sized models. One stone spanned wider than most home ovens, while others barely had enough girth to accommodate a large pizza. For more square footage, we preferred rectangles to rounds, and deeper-browning clay and stone models to cement. The latter material not only produced spotty, pale crusts but emitted noxious fumes. Our previous favorite from Old Stone Oven couldn’t be beat, crisping crusts on a roomy, foot-elevated surface that eased lifting.

less

Buying a Baking Stone

The best baking stone in the world does you no good if it is not the proper fit for your oven.

Watch the Video

In My Favorites
Please Wait…
Remove Favorite
Add to custom collection